Perhaps it is time for freemasonry to come out of the cloisters. It does not require a belief in the super-natural to accept that Old Testament narratives can be a basis for moral and ethical lessons. What more is required? If a person wants to please a supernatural entity then perhaps a worshiping priest would be more appropriate than a worshipful master. Freemasonry provides a moral compass, derived from the workplace and applied to the rest of life on this earth; it was never intended for the acquisition of favours beyond space and time.
The ritual is fine as long as it is understood as secular ritual and not religious liturgy. For Freemasonry to have contemporary and future relevance it must explicitly and demonstrably cut the apron strings that bind it to religion, grow up and stand on its own secular feet. In so doing it can be open and visible for the cause of humanity; in modern definition, transparency is honesty.
Books You Might Enjoy:
Rosemary Ellen Guiley - The Encyclopedia Of Witches Witchcraft And Wicca
Marcus Cordey - Magical Theory And Tradition
Hermes Trismegistus - Book Xiv Of Operation And Sense
Eliphas Levi - The Conjuration Of The Four Elements